Author Talk: Jane Savidge on Pulp’s ‘This is Hardcore’
For the latest installment of 360’s long-running “Author Talk” series, we spoke with Jane Savidge, author of the fascinating new 33 1/3 book on Pulp’s This Is Hardcore. Formed in Sheffield, England, in 1978 by singer and lyricist Jarvis Cocker, Pulp toiled in obscurity for years until they broke through in the 1990s. A much bigger band in their native U.K., Pulp would notch 12 UK Top 40 hits during their initial 24-year run. This Is Hardcore, their sixth album released in 1998, spawned the hit singles “Help the Aged,” “Party Hard,” “This Is Hardcore,” and “A Little Soul.”
Unlike Britpop acts Oasis and Blur, chart success in the U.S. largely eluded Pulp. However, they built a cult following in the states and garnered critical acclaim for their clever lyricism and anthemic synth-laden pop-rock. Pitchfork’s 2017 retrospective list of the 50 Best Britpop albums ranked This Is Hardcore #7, while their 1995 Mercury Prize-winning album Different Class topped the list. Pulp is currently on a reunion tour, with the first North America stops in over a decade coming this fall.
Author Jane Savidge is an accomplished music publicist who is widely credited as one of the primary initiators of the Britpop movement in the 1990s. Pulp, Suede, Elastica, and The Verve were among the many bands Savidge promoted. In this exclusive interview, Savidge discusses why This Is Hardcore is her favorite Pulp record, the album’s dark title track, Cocker’s infamous Michael Jackson incident, and more.
Editor’s Note: This Q&A has been edited for length and clarity. Scroll to the bottom to view the full video interview.
360°Sound: A lot of people associate Pulp with the album Different Class and its smash hit “Common People.” This is Hardcore was the follow-up, and while critically acclaimed, it was less commercially successful. Why did you decide to write a 33 1/3 book on this Pulp album?

Jane Savidge: It’s my favorite Pulp record. It’s got more depth than any other Pulp record. Different Class came out in ’95 and spawned “Common People” and “Sorted for E’s & Wizz,” which both peaked at #2. This Is Hardcore didn’t come out until ‘98. That’s an eon. It took such a long time to get released, and there were many reasons for that. Pulp headlined Glastonbury in ‘95, subbing in for the Stone Roses. I thought it’d be far too easy to write about Different Class, maybe someone else can do that.
Pulp had formed in 1978 so by the time they had some kind of success in ‘95 that was 17 years. In February ‘96, they appeared at the Brit Awards, where they got nominated for four awards. They didn’t get any of them, and that’s when Michael Jackson appeared on stage to perform “Earth Song” surrounded by prepubescent children shortly after he settled with the Jordan Chandler family [over child sexual abuse allegations]. When Jackson got on stage, Jarvis decided to take matters into his own hands and got on stage, and waggled his fully clothed bum at the audience, making a strange wafting gesture with his hands, because he thought Jacko was trying to be some kind of messiah and protector of children or whatever. He got accused in that moment of actually knocking children off stage. That didn’t happen. He got arrested and then bailed.
This made him so famous that he would walk down the street and police would see him walking down the street and come up to him. He thought he was gonna be arrested and they just wanted his autograph. So this was a level of fame that he wasn’t expecting even after 18 years. He wanted to be famous like an astronaut, not famous like a freak for showing his bum on stage. So that sent him spiraling into self-doubt. He ran away to New York to the Paramount Hotel, checked in, and assumed a fake name.
He was coming to the conclusion that this kind of fame is very odd, like pornography, where you examine every single type of your body and personality. The media examined you. It’s very unwholesome. He didn’t like it. He decided to write a record about that. It was my contention that this record ended Britpop accidentally, because it was meant to end Pulp’s career. So it’s a very deep record about aging and mortality and pornography. But it’s a beautiful record. So one of the other things I wanted to examine in the book was the nature of fame, and why people want to be famous.
“This is Hardcore,” the title track, is a standout. Steve Mackey, the late bassist, thought it was the best song Pulp ever recorded. You write about being surprised it was picked as a single. What were your first impressions of the song? And what do you think about the song now?
I think it’s even better than I thought it was then. It’s probably my favorite Pulp song of all time, and it’s one of the few songs that’s even better once you’ve seen the video. Most of the videos detract from the song’s worth, I think, but there’s a few, Beastie Boys’ “Sabotage” springs to mind, which make the song even better. It’s a film in itself, a 1950s melodrama, in six or seven minutes. When I first heard it, I remember thinking, “Wow,” and then saying, “So that’s the single, is it?”
Pulp were loved by the media. All the bands we did were loved by the media. The public came second. All the bands we represented were all press bands. They were lyric bands obsessed with lyrics. And because the media like to write about lyrics, that’s why we got so much press. I knew that This Is Hardcore would get an enormous amount of press. If you look at it, maybe 45 magazine articles came out at the time, and maybe 12 or 13 covers came out to coincide with the record.
I knew the press would be easy enough. But I thought because the record seemed to be about drugs and pornography, it will be difficult because people will be examining what on earth Pulp have been up to. I mean, their very first headline was “Death, Porn, Heroin…What’s Eating Jarvis Cocker?” That was on the cover of Select magazine. And they explicitly asked me, have the band been taking heroin? And how are you supposed to answer a question like that? It’s ludicrous.
“Help the Aged” was an unusual single as well in that there aren’t many pop songs about caring for the elderly. You write that it’s easily the most heartfelt song on the album. Cocker was only 33 when he wrote this song. What do you think prompted him to write a song about aging and mortality?
Pulp toured Different Class so much. They were in a tour bus, sleeping in bunks, which are like coffins. I think being in a confined space, and also being examined all the time by the media, you get to look at photographs of yourself, you see yourself aging in front of your own eyes. If you’ve done 50 magazine articles, and someone’s telling you to look at these photographs of you every day when you look different, you might have had a drink or a cigarette or something, I think that makes you very aware of your own mortality.
Jarvis said at the time as much as he realized that everybody ages and the thing about the pop star dream is you’re not meant to age. You’re meant to deny the possibility of aging. But we all age and I think it was Jarvis realizing he was the same age as Jesus — for instance, on the song “Dishes.” They were the same age [and] they’ve got the same initials, J.C. And then there’s this thing that’s in the ether, which if you haven’t achieved anything by the age of 33, by the time Jesus died, what have you achieved? All these things we’re going through Jarvis’s head when he wrote the record, and I think particularly “Help the Aged.”
Why do you think this album marked the end of the Britpop era?
Well, I think there were several contenders. I think Suede probably tried to do it with Dog Man Star as far back as ‘94 because that’s a really sexual and dark record. And then Radiohead tried to do that as well, and Blur with their sort of American sounding record. And Oasis obviously had an album where there was not one song less than five minutes long on it. But because Pulp were an upbeat band with a kind of sense of humor, This Is Hardcore was such a dark record that nobody expected. I thought if they’re doing a record like that, it’s probably the end of everything.
Pulp’s This Is Hardcore 33 1/3 is available for purchase on the Bloomsbury website. Check out the full video interview with author Jane Savidge below.
