Author Talk: Cabe Eaton on his new book ‘How Did This Sh*t Become a No. 1 Hit?’

Ever wonder why so many horrible songs through the years have topped the pop charts? Austin-based writer Cabe Eaton addresses that puzzling phenomenon with his informative and entertaining book, How Did This Sh*t Become a Number 1 Hit?: From WTF to #1 – 50 Bizarre Hits That Took Over the Charts and the Reasons Why.

In the book, Eaton discusses the most baffling songs to top the Billboard Hot 100 across six decades, from 1960’s “Mr. Custer” by Larry Verne to the 2020 hit “Mood” by 24KGoldn. Other entries include The Archies’ “Sugar, Sugar,” The Rolling Stones’ “Angie,” Elton John’s “Island Girl,” Snow’s “Informer,” and Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Lines.” 360°Sound sat down with Eaton to chat about why he decided to include a Beatles chart-topper, the success of a couple of atrocious Motown covers, and the most awful #1 hit of all.

Editor’s Note: This Q&A has been edited for length and clarity. Scroll to the bottom to view the full video interview on our YouTube channel @360degreesound.

360°Sound: Please start by telling us how this book came to be.

Cabe Eaton: I am a guy with a very vast music library at home. About 15 years ago, I had this idea to pick albums and write humor-based reviews of them. While I was doing that, I kept running into these songs that inexplicably topped the charts. It just seemed like I was bound to write a book about these questionable #1 hits.

The title of the book is what came to me first, and it just flowed after that. The writing of it happened quickly because I already had an idea of what songs I wanted to do. In 2025, I self-published it.

Tell us about your criteria for choosing the songs. Some songs were not considered for various reasons, such as they were a soundtrack hit or part of a dance fad.

The song doesn’t necessarily have to be really bad, although it certainly doesn’t hurt. In the intro, I set some arbitrary guidelines. I didn’t want to include bubblegum singles because kids bought that stuff. Songs that were part of a trend, like Rick Dees’ “Disco Duck” and C.W. McCall’s “Convoy,” were kept off because they just explain themselves. They’re horrible songs, but we know why those were hits. Also, songs that were associated with a popular movie, like Prince’s “Batdance” and Sammy Davis Jr.’s “Candy Man,” weren’t included.


In all fairness, I was a fan of a lot of these hits in the book, like “Telstar.” I loved that song, but what was going on? It was this strange instrumental that just fit in a weird part of chart history. It was really a list of songs I came up with, and then I asked, “What was going on at the time that hit topped the charts, as opposed to other chart-toppers that came before or after?”

There are some legendary acts in the book – Stevie Wonder, Chuck Berry, Michael Jackson, the Eagles, The Rolling Stones, and even the Beatles. “Paperback Writer” topped the charts in June 1966. Why was it included?

That’s a sore subject for some to include any Beatle #1. They’re probably my favorite band, and they seem to be most people’s favorite band. To me, “Paperback Writer” is not a terrible song. I always thought it felt like a bland album track or a B-side. If you look at the Beatles singles in 1965, virtually every one of them went to #1.


Capitol, the U.S. record label of the Beatles, pulled “Nowhere Man” off the Rubber Soul album, which came out at the end of 1965, and released it as a single in February 1966. “Nowhere Man” is a great single, and it was obviously influenced by the Byrds because it had a jangly folk sound to it, which was popular at the time. “Nowhere Man” made it inside the top five, but it didn’t top the chart. That broke the streak of six consecutive chart-toppers from the Beatles. So it wasn’t until June when “Paperback Writer” topped the chart – six months after their last #1, “We Can Work It Out.”

Why did a song that’s your run-of-the-mill rock song but nothing substantial hit #1? The answer is right there. People wanted their Beatles. It’s like taking Coke away, then putting out the new Coke, and everyone wants the classic formula again. It was just timing.

Speaking of the Beatles, you write that the absolute worst song in the book is “Stars on 45,” a melody of Beatles hits that went to #1 in 1981.

I stand by that being the worst #1 hit. It was done by this project in the Netherlands called Stars on 45. It’s basically a bunch of Beatles songs in a disco medley. They’re all stitched together, and this is the old Fab Four Beatles, not the Sgt. Pepper Beatles. It’s all these songs from ‘64 and ‘65.


The impressive thing is they re-recorded them. I always thought that that medley was taken from those recordings. It started with snippets of “Venus” by the Shocking Blue and “Sugar, Sugar,” and then it went right into the Beatles songs. “Stars on 45” topped the charts in the summer of ‘81. Now, the conventional thinking is that it went to #1 because John Lennon’s assassination happened in December 1980.

No one could knock that “Bette Davis Eyes” by Kim Carnes off the charts in the summer of ‘81. That song was #1 for five weeks, but for some reason, “Stars on 45” slipped in there and took that number one spot, then slipped back out. So, part of it is that after Lennon’s death, everything was selling by the Beatles, but something happened.


Back in those days, the Hot 100 was determined by Top 40 radio and single record sales. There could have been a conspiracy of DJs calling each other, saying, “Let’s destroy this ‘Bette Davis Eyes’ song.” I don’t know, but some glitch happened, or at least America was distracted for a week, because “Bette Davis Eyes” came roaring right back and spent four more weeks at #1. I never really understood “Stars on 45.” Also, disco was kind of dead by ‘81, so it had a lot of factors acting against it, but it still reached the top.

A couple of songs in the book are Motown covers, “Please Mr. Postman” by the Carpenters and “You Keep Me Hangin’ On” by Kim Wilde. Do you think their success speaks to the appeal and catchiness of the Motown sound?

What happened around ’73 is that songs rode this wave of nostalgia because of the film American Graffiti. Ringo Starr had a #1 hit with the Johnny Burnette cover, “You’re Sixteen.” The Burnette original is in American Graffiti.


The Beach Boys suddenly had a #1 album with Endless Summer, and even though they had great material in the early ‘70s, they were off the radar. Now all these old surfing songs were back in vogue because of American Graffiti. I think the Carpenters caught the tail end of that nostalgia wave with “Please Mr. Postman.”

The Supremes were suddenly popular in the ‘80s again with covers. Phil Collins had his first top 10 as a solo artist with his cover of “You Can’t Hurry Love.” I attribute that in a way to Kim Wilde with “You Keep Me Hangin’ On.” They were such great tunes back in the ‘60s. I think their popularity just carried over into the decades that followed.


What do you hope readers take away from the book?

There’s a lot of humor in the book. It’s half humor and half music nonfiction, and I want people to listen to these songs. I’ve had people disagree with a lot of the tracks, but they still enjoy the book. My two editors disagreed with some of the stuff I added. It’s great to enjoy these songs again or discover these songs.

It’s a pretty easy read. There are a lot of short chapters, but a lot in there as far as what you can discover aside from the songs themselves. You can call me an idiot if you disagree. It’s perfectly fine.

Purchase Cabe Eaton’s book How Did This Sh*t Become a Number 1 Hit?: From WTF to #1 – 50 Bizarre Hits That Took Over the Charts and the Reasons Why.

Watch the full interview with Cabe Eaton on our YouTube channel, @360degreesound:

TRY ANOTHER ANGLE